Butler’s scathing letter to May over Windrush PMQs lie

db commons.png
Labour MP Dawn Butler

Yesterday in the Commons, Theresa May scored a cheap point during Prime Minister’s Questions by giving a dishonest answer to Jeremy Corbyn’s question about the destruction of the landing cards of the ‘Windrush generation’.

May claimed the decision to destroy the cards had been taken in 2009 under a Labour government. This was untrue – but has nonetheless been repeated as fact by almost every news and politics programme, usually with an accompanying claim that Corbyn made an error by not knowing what May’s response would be.

In video footage of the exchange, Labour’s Shadow Women and Equalities Secretary Dawn Butler can be seen shaking her head and saying “It’s not true, it’s not true”.

Now Ms Butler has written a scathing letter to May, advising her that she raised a point of order in the Commons over her dishonesty and asking seven pointed questions:

db letter 1db letter 2

Those questions are:

  1. Were the landing cards destroyed in October 2010?
  2. Who was the Home Secretary when the landing cards were destroyed in 2010?
  3. Were you aware of the above information when you made the statement in the House?
  4. Why did you take the decision to give this potentially misleading statement to the House?
  5. How many Commonwealth citizens have been wrongly deported due to these errors?
  6. When did you decide to tighten immigration controls and create a really hostile environment for illegal immigrants?
  7. Were you warned that your decision to tighten immigration controls, creating a hostile environment, would harm Commonwealth citizens who were not here illegally?

The former head of the civil service last night put beyond question the issue of whether ministers – including Theresa May – were warned of the consequences and dangers of their policies.

It remains to be seen whether Theresa May will answer the letter and be called to account for her lie to MPs and the nation.

Ms Butler’s letter concerning the reinstatement of Tory MP Anne Marie Morris, in spite of her racist comment, is expected today.

The SKWAWKBOX needs your support. This blog is provided free of charge but depends on the generosity of its readers to be viable. If you can afford to, please click here to arrange a one-off or modest monthly donation via PayPal. Thanks for your solidarity so this blog can keep bringing you information the Establishment would prefer you not to know about.

If you wish to reblog this post for non-commercial use, you are welcome to do so – see here for more.


  1. The fact that Theresa May was quite happy to lie, to both parliament and the electorate, about her culpability in the state wrongfully denying it’s citizens of their freedom and causing so much distress and hardship to it’s own citizens just to score a cheap debating point tells us all we need to know about her character.

  2. I have had enough of this callous cruel government. Also had enough of the biased BBC. The prime minister lied even after SKY NEWS pointed out the truth the BBC news team still peddled the lie. That SKY NEWS is more trustworthy than the BBC says it all. Time to boycott the BBC and refuse to pay the licence fee. Who is in charge of BBC NEWS. I am quite old, never broken the law before. I won’t watch or listen to the BBC anymore. They supported May in a lie yesterday when they knew it was an .untruth. They will stoop so low to harm Jeremy Corbyn and protect May. They must hate him or fear him. How he copes I cannot imagine.
    He has more courage and decency i.n his little finger than the snivelling cowards at the BBC will ever have.

  3. Well,John Prescott did say that May lacks empathy and she was caught out in the election last summer,and that incident in Oxfordshire when one voter complained to her about having her benefit cut caught May flat footed.
    No wonder she has a reputation for being seen as ‘shifty’.

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: