JVL condemns Wimborne-Idrissi expulsion, asks supporters to sign open letter

Jewish Voice for Labour (JVL) has issued a statement condemning the expulsion by the Labour party of elected NEC member Naomi Wimborne-Idrissi on a pretext, which Skwawkbox reported last week.

The group has also published an open letter that it is asking supporters to sign:

Naomi Wimborne-Idrissi, articulate anti-racist, labour movement activist and fearless supporter of Palestinian rights, has been expelled from the Labour Party – not despite these qualities but because of them. Jewish Voice for Labour (JVL) is proud to have Naomi as one of its founding members, and as its tireless media officer.

In suspending and then expelling Naomi Wimborne-Idrissi the party has disenfranchised the thousands of members who elected her to the National Executive Committee. They have been deprived of her voice as one of the nine directly elected constituency party representatives. This disregard for democracy is an attack not just on Naomi but on the rights of all members.

Naomi’s expulsion follows a pattern in which the those who disagree with the leadership’s policies are met not with counter-arguments but with silencing. Many honourable and principled socialists have had their memberships terminated. This is McCarthyism that will stand as one of the most shameful episodes in the party’s history. A party led by a senior lawyer has made breaking its own rules as well as denial of natural justice its signature modus operandi.

Disproportionately those who have been processed through Labour’s disciplinary sausage-machine have been Jews. Many of these have been disciplined for their statements on Palestine or on antisemitism. This is not accidental: many Jews are acutely conscious of the injustices done to and still being perpetrated against Palestinians by an Israeli state built on their subjugation. There is a fundamental difference between criticism of Israel and hostility to Jews. But now such criticism has become a disciplinary offence.

Naomi’s qualities are well understood among Party members. Her election was a vindication of the values that she exemplifies. She will be appealing against her expulsion, contesting the flimsy grounds on which it is based and challenging the factional bias evident in the timing of the action against her and the leaking of information about it to hostile media.

JVL will continue to insist on the right to speak up unambiguously for the rights of Palestinians, and to call out the misuse of charges of antisemitism for factional purposes. We stand by all those who have been, and continue to be, hounded out of the party by a leadership which cannot tolerate any diversion from its neo-liberal, pro-imperialist political direction.

Please sign and share the statement below.

Those wishing to sign the letter can do so here.

Keir Starmer’s regime has relentlessly hounded left-wing Jews, targeting them in massively disproportionate numbers.

SKWAWKBOX needs your help. The site is provided free of charge but depends on the support of its readers to be viable. If you’d like to help it keep revealing the news as it is and not what the Establishment wants you to hear – and can afford to without hardship – please click here to arrange a one-off or modest monthly donation via PayPal or here to set up a monthly donation via GoCardless (SKWAWKBOX will contact you to confirm the GoCardless amount). Thanks for your solidarity so SKWAWKBOX can keep doing its job.

If you wish to republish this post for non-commercial use, you are welcome to do so – see here for more.


  1. Naomi’s expulsion was totally foreseeable. Despite Starmers Labour’s best efforts she was elected to the NEC so the only way they could overturn the democratic vote in her favour was to expel her.
    I intend signing the petition in her support but I expect this will be seen as evidence of ” antisemitism” and will be grounds for expulsion too .
    I say this because experience shows that in Starmer’s crazy Zionist Labour party support for a Jewish woman who upholds Palestinian human rights is automatically denounced as antisemitism by the Zionists now in control of the party

    1. Funny, isn’t it, how she’s been expelled more than a year after she allegedly breached party rules. And it’s just coincidence of course that Naomi was expelled on her birthday.

      Needless to say, this is pure, unadulterated evil at work. And as I’ve said on more than a few occasions before, evil just lurves being evil.

  2. As if keef, fat dave and the bullied at school akehurst are gonna have any of it.

    Stable doors ‘n’ all that…It’s time to prevent those who everyone knows are future candidates for expulsion.

    About time the rats were told…Any more expulsions applied retrospectively for (perceived by them) antisemitism, or for so much as liking tweets etc without due process; will result in funding/individual memberships being withdrawn unequivocally.

  3. Walking away has been spoken about here many time. Sadly, walking away is your only choice because you’re going to be booted if you don’t. They don’t like you. They don’t like your values. They don’t like what you stand for.

    All they want is your money and your vote.

    You’ll get nothing in return for this. Remember who has been supporting this bastardised vision of labour and who they in turn try to court.

    Let them pay and vote for Sir Keir’s monster. They’ll be getting fuck all from me.

    Oh, and inb4 Tory enabler.

    Starmer is by far and away the biggest red ribbon Tory enabler I’ve ever had the misfortune of experiencing

  4. Well done slwawky for permitting comments on this important subject. No member of JVL or any of their supporters are safe from expulsion. The venality of this nasty little fascist enterprise has no bounds. What organisation can afford to dismiss people with years of political nous, wisdom and courage and find an equivalence to fill the hole. It can’t and in its search for neoliberalism purity it doesn’t want. That’s p.c for you. Extremism of the centre. It’s not a swastika anymore but a rainbow and their shirts aren’t black or brown but green. Goodbye Starmer, I’ll see you and your mates on the streets, again in my fucking wheelchair.

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: