Video: Byrne’s constituent can’t afford socks for her kids. McVey mocks as Tories jeer

mcvey callous.png
Callous: DWP Secretary Esther McVey

DWP Secretary Esther McVey appeared before MPs again yesterday – fresh from lying last week about her ‘apology’ for lying to them – to answer questions about her department’s disastrous Universal Credit system.

Her original lie last week had been to claim that the National Audit Office said the roll-out of the system was going so well it should be accelerated – when in fact the NAO had said it must be paused until the DWP can cope, because of the hardship its inability to cope were causing.

Ms McVey has not learned any contrition – and certainly no empathy.

Labour’s Liam Byrne stood to talk about the chaos of Universal Credit in his Birmingham Hodge Hill constituency and told Ms McVey about one of his constituents so badly impacted by it that her family can’t afford food – or even socks for her children’s feet.

A situation of such agonising pathos must surely elicit a human response from even a hard-hearted Tory – even if only a token word. Right?


McVey made no reference at all to the poor woman or even her children – just a lame quip about Byrne’s note left for his successor after Labour lost the 2010 general election, while her equally callous colleagues jeered.

Such notes are part of a long parliamentary tradition and are never meant seriously, nor to be taken seriously – but the Tories cynically exploited Byrne’s to create a false narrative of ‘Labour overspending’.

Byrne told the SKWAWKBOX today:

Actually, we were right to do anything and everything to stop a recession made on Wall Street becoming a second Great Depression.

Since then, the Tories have not only given us a slower recovery than after the Wall Street Crash but they’ve doubled the national debt. They actually cut taxes for the richest people and wealthiest companies while axing help for those in need. Ms McVey either doesn’t understand that or, more likely, simply doesn’t care.


Doesn’t care seems a good bet – years ago, as a DWP minister, McVey predicted that the government’s policies would push hundreds of thousands of children into poverty – and the government exceeded that ‘target’ by so much that they wanted to stop measuring it.

Now, under Tory policies, more than one in four children in the UK lives in poverty – around four million, many of them in working families – and that number is expected to rise during this parliament, made even worse by McVey’s determination to press ahead with Universal Credit nationally, in spite of warnings by the NAO and others.

Esther McVey has been contacted for comment.

The SKWAWKBOX needs your support. This blog is provided free of charge but depends on the generosity of its readers to be viable. If you can afford to, please click here to arrange a one-off or modest monthly donation via PayPal. Thanks for your solidarity so this blog can keep bringing you information the Establishment would prefer you not to know about.

If you wish to reblog this post for non-commercial use, you are welcome to do so – see here for more.


  1. Byrne’s a right wing idiot! You’re not going to convince anyone by saying mothers can’t afford socks for their children…it’s just playing into McVey’s hands.
    With regard to the note: Until many Labour MPs stop buying into the Thatcherite lie that we can run out of money and the economy is like a household budget, the Conservatives will always win public trust on the economy. WTF was Bryne doing in the treasury anyway.

  2. and that is why when during summer recess when there technically on holiday they should all be sent out to work in the mess they create, rather than volunteers doing it unpaid for smarmy gits like these, there also should be ministerial accountability and if that means criminal action and jailing a few of them, so be it, about time some of them were led of in chains for there criminal actions and I don’t mean to run the local nick library either

  3. But weren’t the Blairites saying New Labour was no place for those on welfare, and as for the Neo-Lberal Tories they are Barbarians and what do you expect – they know no better.

  4. I’ve got my differences with Byrne, like many comrades, but we should cut the bloke some slack here, when he’s actually on the right side. McVile is a foul piece of work.

    1. ‘Cut him some slack’?

      Jesus H Navas; this is the idiot what actually offered dummkopf schmitt assistance in implementing UC f complete and total fs.

      THIS is EXACTLY what byrne’s about…


      And STILL the toerags get leverage because of the f**king cretinous ‘no money left’ note.

      So no I won’t cut the specious, abhorrent wee gobshite any slack whatsoever, ‘comrade’. He’s every part as much a rat as the rodents on the opposite benches.

      F**k him. And f**k his fellow toerags too.

  5. Byrne walked right in to the note trap, thinking his mates in other neo-lib parties would play the game. Idiot!

    Utterly discredited. Gave the ConDems superb antisocialist propaganda.

    Again, Idiot!

    1. Reginald Maudling did a similar thing in 1964 but he was not so stupid as to write it down!

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: