The battle in Labour’s ‘socialist societies’

The current challenges to Labour’s socialist leadership are being echoed among the socialist societies.

Sources close to former Blair minister Ian McCartney tell SKWAWKBOX that he will stand in February for Chair of the Labour-affiliated Socialist Health Association, as part of a slate the Labour right hopes will replace the current left-wing leadership.

Others thought likely to appear on the leadership slate include Labour First’s Gurinder Singh Josan, who has failed several times to get elected to Labour’s National Executive Committee (NEC), former Camden Council leader Dame Jane Roberts, and current SHA Council members Brian Fisher and Jean Hardiman Smith. More from the right are being recruited to stand for 20 elected Council places. 

Track record

As well as contributing to Labour’s election manifesto, the current SHA leadership was responsible for steering a radical NHS composite motion, to renationalise England’s NHS, through Labour’s 2017 conference (ref 1). The motion was passed unanimously and remains party policy. 

In 2018, the SHA’s leadership had to undertake a lengthy and difficult disciplinary process in order to dispense with the services of a former coordinator whom the organisation said it found had threatened staff at a meeting and attempted to influence the outcome of SHA elections.  

More recently, the largest SHA branch, in Greater Manchester, was suspended for several months following the discovery of a massive sign-up of non-participating members – some of whom proved to be fake – aimed at influencing the make up of delegations to local CLP general committees. The reformed branch is now under new management.

A number of Tory supporters have been boasting on social media of joining socialist societies to try to obtain a vote in Labour’s leadership election.

The SKWAWKBOX needs your support. This blog is provided free of charge but depends on the generosity of its readers to be viable. If you can afford to, please click here to arrange a one-off or modest monthly donation via PayPal or here for a monthly donation via GoCardless. Thanks for your solidarity so this blog can keep bringing you information the Establishment would prefer you not to know about.

If you wish to reblog this post for non-commercial use, you are welcome to do so – see here for more.


  1. You realise your source has fed you something malicious and wrong? You should really check with those you’ve named. A terrible boo boo.

    1. nivekd 01/01/2020 at 12:47 am

      It would be helpful if you could substantiate your claims by providing further details.

    2. Are we to take it from your lack of response that you were telling big fat porkies, who were you trying to protect?

  2. Tory supporters are also infiltrating sites like this to flex their muscles Fortunately they are soon spotted.,because many are not too bright and jump in with hob nailed boots.

    1. Infiltrating? Soon spotted? Could you give one or two examples Joseph?

      And which sites – like skwawkbox – are you referring to?

  3. The following is a clip from an article by Dr Alan Maddison posted on JVLs website on October 2nd, 2019:

    It is worth noting that the estimated prevalence of Islamophobia in members of the Conservative Party (33%) is more than five times that of antisemitism in Labour Party members (6%), yet the media reporting pattern and political narratives would suggest the inverse is true.

  4. Ian McCartney is absolutely appalling.
    I remember when he appeared on the Today Programme and talked about the then Labour government’s achievements.

    All he could mention really was the minimum wage which is actually one achievement.

    Other achievements: Massive loss of life in Iraq due to sanctions and then invasion.

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: