Excl: Enfield/Caliskan scandal grows – ALL black councillors were deselected

enfield all change.png
An Enfield council article’s headline after May’s local elections

The SKWAWKBOX has covered at some length the scandal in Enfield Labour, where the LCF (local campaign forum) oversaw a deeply flawed selection process that saw numerous candidates selected without proper assessment – and was then promptly voted in by them as council leader after they became councillors.

A committee application submitted by one of the candidates showed a serious lack of communication ability – and one of the ‘essential’ questions omitted was the test of that ability.

Now the SKWAWKBOX can reveal a new and shocking aspect of the scandal has emerged in the form of a letter of protest sent by the borough’s black councillors after every sitting black councillor was deselected and replaced, in many cases, by candidates who had benefited from the flawed process overseen by now-council leader Nesil Caliskan.

In a borough where one in five residents is black.

Black cllrs letter1Black cllrs letter2

Worse still, the councillors were deselected from some of the wards with the highest black populations in the borough – and some of the safest seats.


It’s unprecedented…it amounts to a coup by one ethnic group against another

Ex-councillor Don McGowan (image: Enfield BC)

One councillor and one candidate resigned in protest at the blatant discrimination. The councillor, twelve-year veteran Don McGowan, spoke to the SKWAWKBOX today:

In my twelve years as a councillor I’ve never seen anything like this. It’s unprecedented. The black councillors were largely in safe seats – but those who stayed on to fight, reluctantly, were given unwinnable Tory seats.

The safe seats went to – well, to people who had been planning this for some time. And a lot of them were from one particular community – the people who benefited from the whole debacle of the compilation and selection process.

People are truly disappointed. What we’ve now got, basically, are new, inexperienced councillors and a council ‘leader’ with absolutely no experience – apart from three years on the back bench – to run a council.

At first we didn’t know the extent of the manipulation that had gone on in the composition of the panel [of candidates] but we had heard of some serious violations that had gone on – especially in Edmonton, which has one of the highest black populations.

We wrote our letter months before the [3 May] local elections – and we’re still waiting for a reply. We haven’t even had an acknowledgement.

Local organisations representing the African, Somali and Caribbean communities wrote to the regional Labour office as well and I don’t think region even saw fit to reply.

The Labour Party exists to make life better for people from all ethnic backgrounds. I’m flabbergasted that region didn’t seem to have a problem with it all – I would have thought that they’d take people’s concerns seriously enough to at least look at it, but none of us has even had a response.

It’s desperately disappointing, especially given the percentage of those populations that votes Labour.

People across the party are extremely unhappy about it. Longstanding Labour members have a problem with it. Southgate CLP has a problem with it.

I wouldn’t have a problem with it if it had been done democratically, but it wasn’t and they’ve admitted that it wasn’t. Now there’s one particular group that has taken over the council – – it amounts to a coup by one ethnic group against another.

The ‘coup’ by the Labour right in Enfield is especially bitter in view of the widespread, hypocritical – and uncritical – mainstream media coverage of unfounded complaints by the same right-wing factions in neighbouring Haringey.

Council leader Nesil Caliskan and the Enfield Council press office were contacted about the black councillors’ letter and ex-councillor McGowan’s ‘coup’ allegation and asked for urgent comment. Neither has so far responded.


Changes in Haringey were achieved democratically by members and in full accordance with Labour’s rules and procedures. The right-wing purge in Enfield – by the admission of the then-LCF Secretary and now council leader – was not. The Labour Party needs to suspend Enfield Labour group until the matter is thoroughly investigated.

Many local Labour members now feel that the position of new council leader Nesil Caliskan is untenable. It’s hard to disagree.

Note: although all Enfield’s black councillors were deselected, the borough eventually had three because of changes of ward etc

The SKWAWKBOX needs your support. This blog is provided free of charge but depends on the generosity of its readers to be viable. If you can afford to, please click here to arrange a one-off or modest monthly donation via PayPal. Thanks for your solidarity so this blog can keep bringing you information the Establishment would prefer you not to know about.

If you wish to reblog this post for non-commercial use, you are welcome to do so – see here for more.


  1. Although we are inured to it, from any perspective it is utterly reprehensible that not one of the political or media members of the huge chorus of complaint about the Haringey Labour representative changes has paid any attention to these similar processes in a neighbouring borough.

    This stark contrast is the clearest evidence that those politicians and media commentators are co-ordinating their releases; comments; and appearances in a campaign to destabilise left – or merely suspected Corbyn supporting grass roots figures – at any level of significance in the Labour Party or allied movements

  2. The new leader of Enfield Council has come under fire for allegedly planning to hire a political assistant at a time of ongoing spending cuts.

    Leader of Enfield Conservative group Cllr Joanne Laban said it was “outrageous” for new council leader Cllr Nesil Caliskan to consider reintroducing the posts, which were scrapped more than a decade ago after being deemed unnecessary. http://www.enfieldindependent.co.uk/news/16282304.___Outrageous_____Council_leader___s_plans_for_political_assistant_under_fire/

  3. Will you please stop describing this as a left/right fight. For a change members from both sides of the party are united in their condemnation of the mannernis which the selection process was perverted.

    1. That’s a point that has been made in various articles – however, there’s no doubt that in terms of the ‘coup’, it’s been carried out by right-wingers. But other centrists with principles are part of the broad coalition against it

  4. You could weep.
    Need an investigation.
    Right Wing should be held to account.
    As John Lennon once sang: “How do you sleep at night?”

  5. I am confused as to why labour headquarters has not taken on board the made allegations and have ordered a immediate investigation. As a Labour party member (soon to be ex), I am wondering why Joan Ryan is left to her own devices to behave in a appalling manner where she has tempted the Alevi community from Enfield to push through her own political success agendas. The Alevi community is run by a particular group most of whom are from the same family who have all been elected as councillors and the elected Mayor whom I may point out has herself just been elected as a councillor this year and who is very much close to the new council leader. Joan Ryan has is known to be present have attended many family functions of this family– e.g. the wedding of the head of Alevi federations son who is the older brother of the current Mayor of Enfield. There is certainly a level of corporation for example the elected councillor to replace Mr Don McGowan is the daughter of the Nesimi Erbil, who had appeared in court for various matters and was dropped by the labour party and became independent etc… the list can go on… but it is very disappointing to witness all this and see that nothing is taken place.

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: