Labour “moderates”‘ shame on Saudi arms sales vote

On Wednesday, a debate was held in the House of Commons on a Labour motion for the suspension of arms sales to Saudi Arabia. The Saudis have been widely condemned for targeting civilians in Yemen, with one third of air-strikes hitting non-combatants.

The Tory government fought the motion. Hardly surprisingly, since it has completely abdicated its international obligations.

International treaties to which the UK is a signatory, as well as commitments under EU rules and the UK’s own regulations, say that arms export licences cannot be granted if there is a risk weapons will be used in a ‘serious violation of international humanitarian law’. Parliament is well aware that there is more than just a ‘risk’ of this in Yemen:

saudi1

In spite of this, in a remarkable answer to a written Parliamentary question, Defence Secretary Michael Fallon stated that it wasn’t the UK government’s business where and when the Saudis drop bombs supplied by the UK:

saudi4

No wonder that arms sales continue to climb relentlessly, with Saudi Arabia the biggest buyer of UK-produced weapons:

But you expect this kind of morally-bankrupt venality from the Tories, who fit as comfortably into the pockets of big business as a kangaroo joey into the pouch of its marsupial mother. It’s in their nature.

But from Labour MPs? Labour’s motion was defeated by 90 votes. 98 Labour MPs abstained. Labour could have carried the motion by 8 votes. (A handful of MPs were unable to be present because of serious illness, family circumstances etc, but these are not included in these numbers)

To support a Tory government – even passively – is disgraceful for Labour MPs.

To support a Tory government against a ‘Party whip’ (an official device that means an MP is rebelling against his/her party) is unconscionable – and this was a whipped vote:

clewis

To support a Tory government to defeat a motion to stop them supplying weapons that are being brutally used to kill and main innocent civilians, including women and children, is unforgivable.

So, who are those MPs who helped to condemn the motion to defeat and countless more innocent Yemeni husbands, fathers, wives, mothers, children, siblings and parents to death and disfigurement inflicted by weapons made in and sold by the UK?

A full list of all the MPs who voted for and against Labour’s motion can be found here, but here is a selection of names you will recognise who cannot be found in either column, because they abstained

yemen6

A starving Yemeni child. No apologies that it is a distressing image. It should be.

Alison McGovern
Wes Streeting
Jamie Reed
Jon Woodcock
Stephen Kinnock
Angela Eagle
John Spellar
Ruth Smeeth
Caroline Flint
Gloria de Piero
John Mann
Tom Blenkinsop
Margaret Beckett
Kevan Jones

and many more.

 

If those names look familiar, it is likely because they are among Corbyn’s most venomous opponents. Many have also been among the most vocal in making unevidenced claims of ‘abuse’. It seems they consider an online insult to be abuse, but not a bomb dropped on a wedding or funeral.

And not only that, but they apparently feel so strongly that it’s ok to keep selling arms for that purpose that they were prepared to defy the party whip rather than vote against further sales.

The SKWAWKBOX was not the only one to recognise the hypocrisy signalled by the decision to abstain:

mehdi

This blog would never suggest that the abstentions had any connection with the fact that at least some of the abstainers attend swanky dinners thrown by arms companies.

They might just be shitty human beings.

Whatever their motives, they made it clear why the Labour party in which they felt at home haemorrhaged support for years and why so many people recognise and are inspired by Jeremy Corbyn’s integrity, moral courage and incorruptibility.

Clearer still why their replacement by better candidates is essential both for Labour’s electoral prospects and for its forward momentum.

And blindingly obvious why they appear to have little to fight him with than cynical manoeuvering and baseless smears.

 

6 responses to “Labour “moderates”‘ shame on Saudi arms sales vote

  1. Reblogged this on Sid's Blog and commented:
    Did you abstain?
    Alison McGovern
    Wes Streeting
    Jamie Reed
    Jon Woodcock
    Stephen Kinnock
    Angela Eagle
    John Spellar
    Ruth Smeeth
    Caroline Flint
    Gloria de Piero
    John Mann
    Tom Blenkinsop
    Margaret Beckett
    Kevan Jones
    Did you?

    Like

  2. I’m not sure that the motion actually called for a stop in arms sales, but it did ask for a full investigation (which Boris Johnson has been obstructing).

    I was not surprised to see that my MP, Peter ‘Progress’ Kyle from Hove didn’t vote, although he has subsequently claimed to have been paired – which I thought very rare for three line-whips. Lucy Powell has also said that she was paired.

    Peter Oborne is, as usual, worth reading on this (if only his style of principled Tory was more prevalent today):

    http://www.middleeasteye.net/columns/reign-british-neo-cons-and-party-war-128790447

    Like

  3. Pingback: Labour Yemen rebels support slaughter to provoke Corbyn – and he has to take the bait | The SKWAWKBOX Blog·

  4. Pingback: Reed’s resignation gets rid of one of Labour’s worst but means ‘battle stations’ | The SKWAWKBOX·

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s