Analysis

Video: “There’s no defence against defence” – international law expert destroys Israel’s excuses for genocide

International law expert Ralph Wilde spoke to Al Jazeera about Israel’s genocide in Gaza and the rights of Palestinians to resist – even armed resistance – the illegal occupation. His analysis exploded the excuses of the Israeli regime and its apologists – and their usual demand for acknowledgement of ‘Israel’s right to exist’.

Wilde, a widely recognised and published expert on legal matters relating to territory and colonisation, was clear that:

• Israel has no legal right to exist as an ethnically-dominated ‘Jewish state’ – not just occupying Gaza and the West Bank but at all
• sanctions and other measures to end its occupation are a legal duty for other states
• non-recognition of a state in any sense, resulting in its complete diplomatic isolation, is an correct international response
• Israel, as the illegal occupier and land-stealer, has no right to self-defence against Palestinian resistance because the Palestinians are defending themselves against Israel’s occupation and violence: “there is no defence against self-defence”
• Israel has illegally occupied Gaza continuously long before 2023 – the claim that ‘it all began on 7 October’ is nonsense
• an appeal to security concerns is no excuse for continuing or increasing occupation and violence, let alone for genocide, starvation, extermination, forced transfer and the creation of concentration camps and deportation centres
• the only possible legal basis for Israel’s existence is as a democratic state in which all inhabitants have equal rights and powers – as far from the current fascist, apartheid ethno-state as could be

Watch the relevant parts of the interview here:

Israel is an illegitimate, rogue colony that should long have been isolated as a pariah, not supported as an imperialist terror state by the UK or any other state that wants to claim any respect for or adherence to international law.

One-Time
Monthly
Yearly

Make a one-time donation

Make a monthly donation

Make a yearly donation

Choose an amount

£5.00
£10.00
£20.00
£3.00
£5.00
£10.00
£50.00
£75.00
£100.00

Or enter a custom amount

£

Your support is hugely appreciated.

Your support is hugely appreciated.

Your support is hugely appreciated.

DonateDonate monthlyDonate yearly

If you wish to republish this post for non-commercial use, you are welcome to do so, but please include the donor information above – see here for more.

14 comments

  1. Absolutely bang on!
    The Balfour Declaration said “A Home” for Jewish people in Palestine but not a country or state which Zionists had been pressing for at the time.
    Oh and the White Western Elite from thousands of miles away decided this top down and never consulted the indigenous Palestinian population.
    And it also said that this should not do
    anything that was to the detriment of the Palestinian population.
    The UK a while back had to hand Hong Kong back because of a 200 year old deal
    so it’s absolutely clear The Balfour Declaration has been broken for 108 years!
    As Palestinian intellectuals Said & Olymar have argued – One Multi-Ethnic Democratic State of Palestine from the rivers to the sea.
    Yours in Peace.

  2. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=PMuHGrOB_v0&t=14s&pp=2AEOkAIB

    Francesca Albanese “Israel is responsible for one of the cruelest genocides in modern history” 7 Jul 2025

    In her address to the Human Rights Council on 3 July 2025, Francesca Albanese, the UN Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights in the Palestinian territories occupied since 1967, warned of a genocide unfolding in Gaza and the West Bank. She described the situation as “apocalyptic,” stating that “Israel is responsible for one of the cruelest genocides in modern history.” With over 200,000 Palestinians reported killed or injured and the real toll “far higher,” she accused Israel of dismantling humanitarian aid in Gaza, replacing it with a “so-called ‘Gaza Humanitarian Foundation’ [that] is nothing else than a death trap.” She emphasized that this was not an isolated crisis but part of a decades-long “settler colonial project of erasure” that has intensified in recent months through military force, starvation, and mass displacement.
    Albanese condemned the deep complicity of corporate and state actors in what she called an “economy of genocide.” She detailed how arms manufacturers, surveillance firms, banks, tech giants, and universities profit from the occupation, while “colonies spread, financed by banks and insurers, powered by fossil fuels and normalized by tourism platforms.” She stressed that this is not just about “wrongful conduct” but about a global system that sustains apartheid and enables ethnic cleansing. Citing international legal obligations, she called for a “full arms embargo on Israel,” suspension of trade agreements, and immediate disengagement from any business activity contributing to international crimes. “What I exposed is not a list, it is a system,” she said, urging the world to act before it’s too late: “What comes next depends on all of us… It’s not a question of if, it’s just a question of when.”

      1. Francesca Albanese must be doing something right, she’s really pissed off Trump

        https://www.politico.com/news/2025/07/09/rubio-united-nations-sanctions-00445149
        Secretary of State Marco Rubio announced new sanctions on Wednesday targeting a top U.N. Human Rights Council official who has been critical of Israel’s offensive in Gaza, alleging the human rights expert has spearheaded a “campaign of political and economic warfare against the United States and Israel.”

        Last week, U.N. Human Rights Council Special Rapporteur Francesca Albanese called for the International Criminal Court “to investigate and prosecute corporate executives and/or corporate entities,” with Albanese alleging war crimes perpetrated by Israel amid its war with Hamas.

      2. “Francesca Albanese must be doing something right, she’s really pissed off Trump”

        And yet nowhere in that Politico article is Trump mentioned. Even in passing.

        It’s all “The United States will continue to take whatever actions we deem necessary to respond to lawfare and protect our sovereignty and that of our allies,” Rubio said.”

        and……

        “campaign of political and economic warfare against the United States and Israel.”

        The convenient front man Trump increasingly does most, if not all, of his policy pronouncement on the ineptly named ‘truth social’ platform anyway. The notion that Trump is driving policies like this, which would require a degree of concentration and attention which are beyond him, is simply untenable.

        This is the Deep State/MIC/Swamp once again flexing its flabby muscles on behalf of its handlers because someone has had the temerity to refuse to cry ‘uncle’ and not do what the dictatorship demands.

        Given that the out of control death cult known as TINA is already sanctioning a large chunk of the planet, it cannot be too much longer before the Oligarchy in the US and the West start to sanction their own subjects.

        They’ve already recently all but buried the fourteenth Amendment in the United States of Chaos:

        https://www.nationalworld.com/news/opinion/the-us-supreme-court-just-ripped-up-the-fourteenth-amendment-britain-should-be-paying-close-attention-5216047

    1. “Albanese condemned the deep complicity of corporate and state actors in what she called an “economy of genocide.” She detailed how arms manufacturers, surveillance firms, banks, tech giants, and universities profit from the occupation, while “colonies spread, financed by banks and insurers, powered by fossil fuels and normalized by tourism platforms.” She stressed that this is not just about “wrongful conduct” but about a global system that sustains apartheid and enables ethnic cleansing.”

      A statement which implicitly spells out that Israel is, among others like their fascist counterparts in Ukraine and the Syrian Jihadist head choppers feted by Uncle Tom Lammy this week, mere proxies of larger Western elite interests.

      A reality which will require more than just the isolation of Israel or even the end of the Israeli ethno-supremacist state to prevent further similar events across the globe arising from a system which is larger, more insidious and more powerful than the Mafia:

      1. As Alex Krainer points out……..

        https://trendcompass.substack.com/p/defeat-of-the-wests-strategy-of-chaos

        “……….. we’re not observing a chain of unrelated conflicts: all these wars are only different battlegrounds in the same clash between opposed systems of governance: the Western imperial system against all who refuse to submit to it. In this sense, the war in Ukraine, Gaza, Lebanon, Syria, Iran, Afghanistan and Pakistan are all related. They are related in another way: Western empire is also losing in all of them. Perhaps the most important war is that between Russia and Western proxy Ukraine, where the comprehensive defeat of the West is imminent.

        Israel, West’s proxy in the Middle East has also been strategically defeated with the failure of their air defence systems during the 12-day war. Western powers also failed to contain Yemen’s Ansarallah and to effect a regime change in Iran.”

        The Western oligarchy, particularly in Britain, is quite prepared to continue the fantasies of Rhodes and Makinder down to the last Jew as well as the last Ukrainian and anyone else gullible enough to do what Blackrock Merz observed as their (the oligarchy’s) ‘dirty work’ for them.

        The ‘system’ as Albanese accurately describes it will need to be totally dismantled and all its participants eliminated if complete global chaos is going to be prevented.

      2. Thanks for loading “The Spider’s Web: Britain’s Second Empire” here Dave. It’s a great film. The first 23mins provides essential inf. for informed lefties. (and the whistleblower inf later on damns Blair and Starmer more than ANY Conservative “bought politician”.
        Every time I’ve tried to access the film on (the vile) YouTube, it insists on re-CAPCHA (aka “Gotcha f*cker!”) and registration/sign in which I absolutely refuse to provide.
        Thanks, greatly Dave – greatly appreciated.

      3. Third time ‘lucky’?

        https://

        vimeo.com/

        290438534

  3. Perhaps the Neo-Liberal capitalists have problems and there is (a) a crisis of over
    production?
    “There is too much entry into the market and not enough exit?” (FT).
    And (b) the Lumpen Neo-Liberals have painted themselves into a corner with their
    50 year drive for CHEAP LABOUR but
    “Commodities need consumers!”
    And as Wolfgang Streekt argues “The rich and powerful haven’t a clue what to do!”
    The only solution is every country to follow
    a Corbyn type left wing democratic socialist programme, ending poverty etc & putting pounds in peoples pockets +
    building peace & international co-operation between all countries which is actually free.
    But perhaps Gramsci had their number: “We live in an Age of Monsters.”
    And also perhaps need to update some great old slogans.
    “Diverse workers of the world unite!”
    And “Left Wing Democratic Socialism (With not For) or Barbarism?”
    Solidarity.

Leave a Reply to Dave HansellCancel reply

Discover more from SKWAWKBOX

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading