Video: #Budget17 stamp duty change helps almost no one and misses real issue

One of the few supposedly noteworthy aspects of Philip Hammond’s Budget today was the abolition of stamp duty for first-time buyers on house purchases below £300,000. Sounds nice, but in fact it benefits almost nobody – except those who already own a high-priced home.

Office of Budget Responsibility (OBR) Chair Robert Chote explained that the abolition would in fact increase house prices by more than the stamp duty saving, so those selling a home would gain but not those buying:

The OBR’s formal report also said that the number of home-buyers who would be enabled to buy a home by this measure is a tiny 3,500 – and the change does nothing whatever to address the far larger issue of the scale of deposit first-time buyers need to save: an average of almost £33,000 across the country, according to the Halifax.

The maximum threshold to receive any benefit from the change is a house price of £500,000 – a penny higher and all discounts are lost. But to be able to afford to benefit at the top end of the range – which would apply to almost everyone buying in London or other expensive parts of the country, buyers would need an income of over £140,000 a year just to qualify for a mortgage.

And far higher for those who also have student debts to repay.

And that’s the key flaw with the Tories’ token gesture – it’s a demand-side change that does nothing to address the overheated housing market that has forced house prices to unaffordable levels in many parts of the country.

For the very richest, or those with rich parents, the new measure amounts to yet another tax-cut for the wealthy. But to change the real problem – shortage of supply – will require far bolder and more decisive issues than a weak Tory government and a managerial Tory Chancellor are capable of.

The SKWAWKBOX needs your support. This blog is provided free of charge but depends on the generosity of its readers to be viable. If you can afford to, please click here to arrange a one-off or modest monthly donation via PayPal. Thanks for your solidarity so this blog can keep bringing you information the Establishment would prefer you not to know about.


  1. Rich rentiers holding property for profit keep prices high.
    They can’t wait for the next crash so they can pick up another tranche of foreclosure bargains from their friends the bankers.

    1. Lease buyers also affected. I didn’t know some new houses, as well as flats were now sold as leasehold and the freehold can then be sold on, increasing costs.
      Pretty shocking discussion showing how this system also favours Rentiers who siphon more and more from their victims.
      Many sectors of society are being fleeced not just the less well off, The siphoning system to banks and Rentier classes is creeping up the income scale.

  2. Again and again “we”, not the Royal “we”!
    The ordinary people, get shafted, by the neoliberal right!
    What do they know, about living from hand to mouth, going without food, so their children don’t starve!
    Having the worry about paying their bills, clothing themselves and their children!

    “Hammond”, the richest MP in parliament, handling our taxes, to pay for the cockups, they and their rich cronie mates MADE AND MAKE, while in power!

    Time for the left to make a proper job, of running our country!
    I have had enough, of the RIGHT totally sticking us with AUSTERITY,
    to make them richer and us poorer.

    There isn’t a day goes by without some rich bidder, at a top auction, spends our TAXES on paintings, cars, land and houses that they got returned to them, by this Tory GOVERNMENt!


Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: