Jewish campaigners for Palestine have expressed their disgust and anger at the government’s “dismissive treatment” of them in its decisions on the policing of anti-genocide protest. And they have done so direct to PM Andy Burnham and his ministers.
In a letter to Burnham today, Jewish Voice for Liberation (JVL) co-chair Jenny Manson expresses the group’s outrage at policing minister Sarah Jones’s failure to engage – and she points to the many Jews who oppose Israel’s genocide and the ideology behind it:
Dear Prime Minister,
Please see our latest email to Sarah Jones attaching today’s statement.
The last two paragraphs express the desperation of the many Palestinian supporting Jews whose voice is not heard.
“It is particularly offensive to ignore those who experienced the horrors of the Holocaust, either directly or through our family histories, when we oppose the current atrocities being perpetrated by Israel against the Palestinian people, supposedly in the name of all Jews.
“We call on the government publicly to acknowledge that there are many Jews who support the Palestinian cause, condemn the actions of Israel and oppose Zionism. In the short term, we call on ministers to live up to their commitment to ‘meaningful engagement’ and agree to a meeting with us, as we have requested.”
“Antisemitic” stereotyping
The joint JVL/Holocaust Survivor Group statement, which points out the government’s “antisemitic” kowtowing to pro-Israel Jewish groups and its “dismissive treatment” of those who stand up for humanity, reads:
THE GOVERNMENT’S DISMISSIVE TREATMENT OF PRO-PALESTINE JEWS
On 28 October 2026 we wrote to Sarah Jones, Minister for Policing, and her colleague Florence Eshalomi, Minister for Communities and Faith, to request a meeting in order to put to them our concerns about the government’s treatment of those Jews who support Palestine, condemn the actions of Israel and oppose Zionism. We find it disappointing and discourteous that we have not even had an acknowledgement, let alone a proper response.
Our request for a meeting followed an unsatisfactory correspondence that had lasted for over six months. We, along with more than 40 descendants of Holocaust survivors, initially wrote to the then Prime Minister (Starmer), the Home Secretary and the Commissioner of the Metropolitan Police in May 2026 refuting allegations that pro-Palestine marches are a source of danger for Jewish people. This was followed up by a letter to the incoming new Prime Minister about the government’s response to Jews who support Palestinian rights.
Since then, we have had three letters from the two ministers, in some cases taking more than two months to reply. These letters were dismissive in tone and consisted largely of generalised statements of government policy, much of it irrelevant to the issues we raised.
However, we were encouraged that in her last letter Ms Jones did acknowledge that “this Government recognises the diversity of our Jewish communities” and went so far as to say “that is why we are committed to meaningful engagement with a range of different voices and perspectives.”
In view of this, we requested a meeting to present our concerns and ensure that they were properly heard in order to achieve such a ‘meaningful engagement’. Taking into account the length of time that the correspondence had taken, we asked for a reply within two weeks; now three weeks have passed and we have not even had an acknowledgement.
It is offensive that Jews who support the Palestinian people, condemn the criminal actions of Israel and oppose Zionism are treated in this offhand manner. We note the complete contrast to the government’s approach to Jewish groups that support Israel and Zionism.
While there are well-documented reports of numerous repeated meetings at many levels of government, from the Prime Minister down, with pro-Israel organisations and individuals, we are not aware of either the Prime Minister or his predecessor holding a single meeting with Jewish pro-Palestine or anti-Zionist organisations or individuals Ignoring the many Jews who do not conform with the established narrative of universal support for Israel and Zionism is a position that is itself antisemitic, as it generalises about Jews, reduces them to stereotypes, denies them individuality and agency, and may even endanger their safety, by suggesting that they all support Israel’s genocidal actions in Palestine.
It is particularly offensive to ignore those who experienced the horrors of the Holocaust, either directly or through our family histories, when we oppose the current atrocities being perpetrated by Israel against the Palestinian people, supposedly in the name of all Jews.
We call on the government publicly to acknowledge that there are many Jews who support the Palestinian cause, condemn the actions of Israel and oppose Zionism. In the short term, we call on ministers to live up to their commitment to ‘meaningful engagement’ and agree to a meeting with us, as we have requested
Manson told Skwawkbox that her members are “aghast” at the Burnham government’s refusal to engage with Holocaust survivors and other pro-Palestine Jews:
We are not surprised but still we are aghast at the government’s failure to meet with the Holocaust survivors and their descendants group to get their take on what campaigning for Palestine means to them – AND how absurd, counter-productive and dangerous it is to muzzle campaigning (and to suggest that all or even most Jews in the UK support Israel right or wrong).
Header image: Jewish Anti-Zionist Congress.
Skwawkbox needs your help. If you can do so without hardship, here’s how:
To make a regular donation via GoCardless, click here.
To make a regular or one-off donation via PayPal, click here.
Or to make a regular or one-off donation by simple card payment, use the form below:
Make a one-time donation
Make a monthly donation
Make a yearly donation
Choose an amount
Or enter a custom amount
Your support is hugely appreciated.
Your support is hugely appreciated.
Your support is hugely appreciated.

