Breaking – leading Jews to tell Starmer: “Proscribe genocide, not protest!”

Group will deliver letter tomorrow demanding immediate and unconditional recognition of Palestinian statehood, a complete trade and arms embargo and more

Leading British Jews will be at Downing Street tomorrow, Tuesday 5 August, at 2pm to deliver a letter to Keir Starmer to tell him to fight genocide not protest and that they consider the proscription of Palestine Action to be illegitimate and unethical.

A delegation will deliver the letter, to Keir Starmer and Home Secretary Yvette Cooper, signed by three hundred Jews. Lead signatories include:

· leading human rights lawyer Sir Geoffrey Bindman KC
· film director Mike Leigh
· author Michael Rosen
· writer Gillian Slovo
· author and former ANC MP Andrew Feinstein

Jenny Manson, Chair of Jewish Voice for Labour and lead organiser of the letter said:

We are Jews horrified by the genocide being carried out by Israel against the Palestinian people. We oppose genocide as human beings. We oppose it because we are Jews who have learnt from our history to be vigilant against injustice, and to stand up for justice for all people everywhere.  For us, ‘Never again’ does not mean only crimes against Jews but Never Again by anyone to anyone.

We will be standing together in Whitehall on Tuesday 5th August between 2 and 4pm, to demonstrate our horror at Israel’s actions and to call on our Government to take real action now. 

Among the speakers addressing the rally will be:

· Andrew Feinstein: Son of a Holocaust survivor, former ANC MP, stood against Keir Starmer in Hamstead and St Pancras in 2024
· Joseph Finlay:  Historian, musician and writer on British Jewish issues
· Gillian Mosely:  Documentary maker, descended from several famous rabbis
· Alexei Sayle: Comedian, author, lifelong supporter of Palestine

The letter will stress the horrific reality of Israel’s genocide in Gaza and the lack of excuse for inaction when the horror is agonisingly on show every day on radio, television and social media. The group says:

Criticising Israel and opposing the brutality of genocide, apartheid, and ethnic cleansing taking place in Gaza and the West Bank, including taking direct action, are not antisemitic. Nor are they terrorism. We consider the proscription of Palestine Action to be illegitimate and unethical.

It is time to end the government’s handwringing over the level of slaughter and suffering in Gaza and the West Bank, mixed with tacit support to the Israeli state.

The Government must immediately recognise the state of Palestine, without threats and conditions, and initiate meaningful sanctions:

·         Suspending the UK-Israel trade agreement.

·         Ending all exports used by the Israeli military in weapons or otherwise.

·         Ending all UK military and intelligence collaboration with Israel.

·         Banning imports from Israel.

·         Questioning the Israeli ambassador to the UK about her support for genocide.

·         Informing UK citizens participating in the Israeli military that they risk prosecution for war crimes.

The letter that will be delivered reads:

To Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer and Home Secretary Yvette Cooper

Proscribe genocide, not protest

We are Jews who oppose the genocide by Israel against the Palestinian people, the reality of which is agonisingly on show every day on radio, television and social media. Opposing the brutality of genocide, apartheid, and ethnic cleansing taking place in Gaza and the West Bank, including taking direct action, is not antisemitic. Nor is it terrorism. We consider the proscription of Palestine Action as illegitimate and unethical.

We oppose genocide as human beings. We oppose it because we are Jews who have learnt from our history to be vigilant against injustice and stand up for justice for all people, everywhere. For us, ‘Never again’ does not mean only crimes against Jews, let alone criticism of Israel, but never again by anyone to anyone.

The International Court of Justice identified Israel’s behaviour in Gaza as possible genocide. It is now widely recognised as actual genocide. Dozens and dozens of analyses by respected human-rights organisations and genocide scholars throughout the world have all now reached the same conclusion. We draw your attention to three of the examples, the late July 2025 B’Tselem “Our Genocide” publication, the report “Amnesty International investigation concludes Israel is committing genocide against Palestinians in Gaza” on 5^th December 2024 and Israel historian Omer Bartov’s reluctant acceptance of this view in the New York Times in “I’m a Genocide Scholar. I Know It When I See It. “(15^th July 2025)

Further we also note the ICJ’s insistence that once it had identified the risk of genocide by Israel, the obligation on other states was to ensure they were not complicit, to halt genocide if it had happened, and to prevent it if it looked likely to happen.

The actions of the UK government expand on a disturbing trend of attempts by successive governments to restrict peaceful protests intended to save lives. Lengthy prison sentences have been given to climate protesters as well as those opposed to arms sales to Israel. It has made the UK among the most repressive countries in Europe according to UN representatives, especially since the proscription of Palestine Action.

Article 10 of the Human Rights Act specifies the right to freedom of expression which includes the right to take non-violent direct action in accordance with one’s conscience even where this involves civil disobedience. This has long been a route to achieving progressive change in society, for example in the courage of the suffragettes. Shortly before the debate on proscribing Palestine Action, many MPs were pictured wearing sashes expressing solidarity with the suffragette movement amongst whom the use of direct action was extensive. Direct action was also an integral part of the civil rights movement in the USA, and the anti-apartheid movement in the UK. It has been an important feature of the struggle to limit ongoing climate catastrophes by protesters around the world as supported by the Aarhus convention which the UK signed in 2005.

Reassurances have been given that the right to protest is protected:

Dan Jarvis, a Minister of State for the Home Office, assured MPs in the House of Commons on 2nd July:

“Proscribing Palestine Action will not impinge the right to protest. People have always been able to protest lawfully or express support for Palestine, and they can continue to do so.”

These words were reinforced by Justice Chamberlain when an interim injunction against the order was sought.

“97. It will remain lawful for the claimant and other persons who were members of PA prior to proscription to continue to express their opposition to Israel’s actions in Gaza and elsewhere, including by drawing attention to what they regard as Israel’s genocide and other serious violations of international law. They will remain legally entitled to do so in private conversations, in print, on social media and at protests. Even if their protests take the form of direct action which involves criminality, the fact that they were previously members of an organisation which is now proscribed would not as a matter of law aggravate their criminal conduct. (our emphasis) It follows that it is hyperbole to talk of the claimant or others being “gagged” in this respect (as the claimant has alleged). They could not incur criminal liability based on their past association with a group which was not proscribed at the time.”

In spite of this, we have seen some extraordinary police action, including this arrest involving Private Eye where a protestor merely carried a poster image of a satirical cartoon previously published without challenge in the magazine and in Kent where Police threatened to arrest a protestor for holding a Palestinian flag. We note the Kent police response, justifying an intervention of theirs, said in words quoted in Haroon Siddique’s Guardian report:

“Under the Terrorism Act it is a criminal offence to carry or display items that may arouse reasonable suspicion that an individual is a member or supporter of a proscribed organisation such as Palestine Action.”

The offending “items” in that instance were a Palestinian flag, the utterance “Free Palestine”, and a poster saying, “Israel is committing genocide’.

We believe that such extraordinary actions show that immediate explanation and clarification to the police are required.

The government should stop deflecting attention from genocide by linking non-violent protest to terrorism. Instead, we call on your government to use its influence to help to end genocide and bring about justice for the Palestinian people. It should immediately recognise the state of Palestine and initiate meaningful sanctions such as:

• Suspending the UK-Israel trade agreement.
• Ending all exports used by the Israeli military in weapons or otherwise.
• Ending all UK military and intelligence collaboration with Israel.
• Banning imports from Israel.
• Questioning the Israeli ambassador to the UK about her support for genocide.

• Informing UK citizens participating in the Israeli military that they risk prosecution for war crimes.

It is time to end the government’s handwringing over the level of slaughter and suffering in Gaza and the West Bank, mixed with tacit support to the Israeli state. The United Kingdom is not powerless in the face of Israel’s breaches of international law and we call on the government to take the tough diplomatic, political and economic action to help end genocide, occupation, apartheid, and ethnic cleansing.

Yours faithfully,

LEAD SIGNATORIES

Sir Geoffrey Bindman KC
Tony Booth
Mark Etkind
Andrew Feinstein
Rob Ferguson
Joseph Finlay
Dr Agnes Kory
Richard Kuper
Mike Leigh
Leah Levane
Jenny Manson
Angie Mindel
Gillian Mosely
Prof Jacqueline Rose
Michael Rosen
Alexei Sayle
Gillian Slovo
Naomi Wayne

Skwawkbox will bring its readers images and footage on the day.

Please remember to support Skwawkbox if you can, to help ensure it can keep running. The site is provided free of charge but depends on the support of its readers to be viable. If you’d like to help it keep revealing the news as it is and not what the Establishment wants you to hear – and can afford to without hardship – please click here to arrange a one-off or modest monthly donation via PayPal or here to set up a monthly donation via GoCardless (Skwawkbox will contact you to confirm the GoCardless amount as it has to be entered by us). Alternatively, if you prefer to make a one-off or recurring donation by simple card payment, please use the form below:

Thanks for your solidarity so Skwawkbox can keep doing its job of inconveniencing the right and helping to build the left!

If you wish to republish this post for non-commercial use, you are welcome to do so, but please include the donor information above – see here for more.