Media & Jarman claim 20k avoidable NHS deaths. Why it’s nonsense.

Just noticed that the Daily Fail ( re-ran Brian Jarman’s old ’20k needless deaths’ claim early on Tuesday morning, ahead of the publication of the Keogh report. There’s no question from the content of their article that the intent was to turn up the heat on Andy Burnham and to try even harder to dislodge Labour as the party of the NHS.
Well, that’s egg, sausage and chips all over their faces now, since Bruce Keogh completely disavowed the 13k deaths claim in a private email ( as well as most emphatically in his report.
The lurid death-headlines, from Mid Staffs to Basildon and Thurrock and every point in between, are now thoroughly discredited – but I’d lay money it’s not the last we’ll see of them. The aims of the government and the right-wing media, and Prof Jarman’s increasingly desperate attempts to restore his dysfunctional statistical system to what he considers its rightful place, fit too well together for them to let little matters like obvious truth stop them trying.
Don’t hold your breath waiting for the Fail to apologise or publicly retract its claims. Do watch out for more rehashed ‘news’ (and no doubt lots of pictures of the equally-dysfunctional Julie Bailey and her Cure mafia), as the media attempts not to let the facts get in the way of a ‘good’ (from their point of view) story.
Since the 20k death myth appears to be persisting even though its as thoroughly nonsensical as the 13k deaths claim, here’s a reblog of why it’s pure, propagandist, nonsense.


In the immediate aftermath of the release of the Francis Report into events at Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust, I identified that David Cameron’s crocodile-tears and apparent humility were just a feint that would quickly turn into an attack on the NHS nationally (yet another front in their all-out war on it), using Mid Staffs as a template for attacking other hospitals – and Labour.

This morning’s headlines – covered by the BBC (website and news channel) and the right-wing press – about Professor Sir Brian Jarman’s claim that 20,000 NHS deaths could have been prevented come on the back of a 2-week long assault by Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt on Labour’s supposed failings leading to Mid Staffs.

The claims are utter nonsense – but they are being used by the press and the government as

A sledgehammer to smash the NHS – and Labour

I’ve already shown, at…

View original post 3,323 more words

19 responses to “Media & Jarman claim 20k avoidable NHS deaths. Why it’s nonsense.

  1. Steve, I am having extreme difficulty accessing links from your site, I do not know whether it is a problem from my computer or your end, have you had any complaints or reason to believe your site is under attack. Mervyn

    Date: Sat, 20 Jul 2013 09:33:37 +0000 To:


  2. I am just disgusted with the whole of the TV and press media plus all the Inconsistences of stories from Julie Bailey and her crew of cure the NHS, that when started was all about patient care but now is just about how much TV and media attention they can get by constantly exaggerating the facts and getting paid for interviews. The next interview will probably have the 20,000 figure increased to 30,000 and they will all have had relatives falling out of bed and drinking out of Invisible Vases all this while the caring lot of cure the NHS sat by there relatives beds and never called a nurse or picked up someone who had supposedly fell on the floor and was in total fear and agony as they sat there looking into there eye’s. What the media haven’t realized yet is that all the nursing staff at Stafford Hospital are related to Genghis Kahn so how do the patients expect to be treated.


  3. Pingback: Media & Jarman claim 20k avoidable NHS deat...·

  4. Steve, please get back to Not The Talk – you’ve got some people who need a little bit of persuading to say the least!


    • Although reading the article they don’t seem to make the logical leap that Keogh’s rubbishing of using mortality rates to estimate unnecessary deaths also applies to Mid-Staffs.


  5. Never knew winkling truth from ‘honest’ professionals can be so time-consuming, stressful, furious-making & depressing. Just don’t know how you do it & keep it up so consistently. A marvel.

    (@teddygroves almost as brilliant at tweet-winkling as Steve..!)


  6. Pingback: Prof Jarman: REALLY an ‘independent’ expert on NHS mortality stats? | The SKWAWKBOX Blog·

  7. “Where did that 13,000 come from? Not from Keogh’s meticulous report. With an innocent face, the health secretary, Jeremy Hunt, protested: “I don’t know how that number was put out there.” It came from No 10 briefers, and was quickly refuted by Keogh, who called it “clinically meaningless and academically reckless”. It was also promoted by Professor Sir Brian Jarman, author of the Dr Foster hospital guide.

    Professor Sir Mike Rawlins, recent chair of the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (Nice), new president of the Royal Society of Medicine, is crisp in his dismissal: “To claim, as Brian Jarman has done, thousands of deaths, is a complete distortion of the statistics.”


  8. Pingback: Mortality stats: govt ‘in bed’ with Dr Foster | The SKWAWKBOX Blog·

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s